Are these any good?

well i decided to make some signatures seeing as i have cs3 are they any good?
Lopunny:


Shiny Electrode:


One for Darkhunter:

Those are really good for a first effort! And thanks for making me one, it's EPIC!

Looks like very little effort was put to them.

They're good, its just lacking artistic value (which you always wanna have, otherwise it would look like you never put any effort to them)

I like them, way better than what i can do!

Nice, those look really good in my opinion.

You should continue your good work and become even better with this.

Not to be mean but, it looks like very little time and effort was put into this. It looks liked you just whipped it up in a few minutes. Art is about the effort you put into it. These aren't bad..but maybe you should look at some tutorials to get better.

Just to let you know before hand. Don't get offended in anyone might say. Negative criticism helps you to improve.

.....Everyone will always like Gaia's instead of yours.
(I feel very bad for you) Of course I'm not going to lie though these were done fast try reading some tutorials. (not that I could do better)

Evil wrote:

Just to let you know before hand. Don't get offended in anyone might say. Negative criticism helps you to improve.

WRONG



constructive critcism helps. Negative just puts people down. By pointing out flaws and giving links to TuT's and youtube vids or some of your own tips can help



Does this help?:


"OMFG U SUCK AT GFX NO TIME IT SUCKS!!!!!"


no...


this?

"I DONT LIKE IT"


no....


this?

I dont like it bc (place reason(s) here.)

try to ( insert tips and things to help here

then im sure you will be very good.









YES IT DOES HELP

GaiaAero wrote:

Not to be mean but, it looks like very little time and effort was put into this. It looks liked you just whipped it up in a few minutes. Art is about the effort you put into it. These aren't bad..but maybe you should look at some tutorials to get better.

Does it help?


YES!!!!!!!

beast wrote:

.....Everyone will always like Gaia's instead of yours.

no! it dont help! Its kind discouraging, how ever its spelled....

well the negative factors will hopefully do the "I need to do better next time"

but oh well :I

i tried

I agree with beast, whenever i'm asked to judge something it's never negative, but, it's also not sugar coated, i tell in a way where it does not offend but does not lie, and does help, all at once.

Oh come on guys, my art isnt THAT good

GaiaAero wrote:

Oh come on guys, my art isnt THAT good

dont contradict the rest of the forum's opinion




i dunno